Aruba vs. St. Thomas (U.S. Virgin Islands)

Welcome to the Caribbean gems of Aruba and St. Thomas! If you’re dreaming of pristine beaches, warm sunshine, and a vibrant island experience, these two tropical paradises are sure to captivate your wanderlust. 

The main difference between Aruba and St. Thomas (U.S. Virgin Islands): Aruba is an autonomous constituent country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands, located in the southern Caribbean Sea. On the other hand, St. Thomas is one of the three main islands that constitute the U.S. Virgin Islands, an unincorporated territory of the United States in the northeastern Caribbean.

While both are popular tourist destinations known for their stunning beaches and vibrant culture, their distinct political affiliations set them apart in terms of governance and administrative systems.

Categories	Aruba	St. Thomas (U.S. Virgin Islands)
Cost Range for 1 Week	$2,274 – $4,782 (source)	$659 – $3,057 (source)
Location	Caribbean; Located off the coast of Venezuela	Caribbean; Part of the U.S. Virgin Islands
Geography	Flat and arid; Lacks natural freshwater sources	Mountainous; Dense vegetation
Language	Dutch, Papiamento, English, Spanish	English
Government	Autonomous constituent country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands	Unincorporated territory of the United States
Currency	Aruban Florin (AWG)	United States Dollar (USD)
Tourism	Major tourist destination with beautiful beaches and resorts	Popular cruise ship port with picturesque beaches
Economy	Tourism, oil refining, offshore banking, and finance	Tourism, manufacturing, retail, and services

Let’s uncover the secrets that make Aruba and St. Thomas the ultimate Caribbean getaway!

Geographical Location and Climate

Aruba and St. Thomas both boast stunning geographical locations and pleasant climates, but each offers its own unique characteristics.

Aruba, located in the southern Caribbean Sea, enjoys a prime spot outside the hurricane belt. Its arid climate creates a desert-like landscape with cacti and divi-divi trees dotting the island. The year-round average temperature is constant and falls between the mid-70s and low 80s Fahrenheit (or the mid-20s to upper 20s Celsius). This makes Aruba an ideal destination for those seeking warm and sunny weather throughout the year.

On the other hand, St. Thomas is part of the U.S. Virgin Islands, located in the northeastern Caribbean. Its climate is tropical, with a slightly higher chance of encountering rain showers compared to Aruba. Most of the year, the temperature stays in the mid-80s Fahrenheit (or about 30 degrees Celsius). The lush green hills and vibrant flora contribute to St. Thomas’ picturesque appeal, capturing the essence of a tropical paradise.

While both locations offer beautiful landscapes and agreeable climates, Aruba stands out for its consistently warm and dry weather, perfect for sun worshippers, while St. Thomas entices visitors with its tropical charm and occasional refreshing showers.

Cultural Diversity and Heritage

Aruba and St. Thomas showcase diverse cultural influences, each with its own rich heritage that reflects the island’s history and people.

Aruba, known as “One Happy Island,” is a melting pot of cultures. Influences from the indigenous Arawak people, Spanish and Dutch colonialism, and Afro-Caribbean traditions have shaped Aruba’s unique identity. Visitors can immerse themselves in the lively local culture, vibrant festivals, and traditional music, such as the rhythmic beats of tumba and the folkloric dances of the Dande.

St. Thomas, as part of the U.S. Virgin Islands, has a distinct blend of African, European, and American influences. Before becoming a US territory, the island’s history was influenced by Danish, Dutch, and British colonization. The American nation’s capital is Charlotte Amalie. Virgin Islands, is renowned for its well-preserved colonial architecture, historic sites like Fort Christian, and bustling markets offering local crafts and jewelry.

Both destinations celebrate their cultural heritage through festivals, arts, and cuisine, providing visitors with a rich tapestry of experiences that showcase the unique blend of traditions and influences that have shaped their respective identities.

Economy and Tourism

The economy of Aruba and St. Thomas heavily relies on tourism, but their approaches and industries differ.

A thriving tourism industry has allowed Aruba to draw tourists from all around the world. The island offers a range of accommodations, from luxurious resorts to cozy beachfront hotels, catering to various budgets and preferences.

Aruba’s tourism infrastructure includes shopping centers, casinos, and a vibrant nightlife scene, making it a popular choice for travelers seeking a lively and bustling vacation experience. The island’s dedication to sustainability and ecotourism is clear in its initiatives to protect its natural resources and encourage ethical travel.

St. Thomas, as a citizen of the U.S. Virgin Islands, benefits from its connection to the United States. The island welcomes cruise ships and tourists who explore its historical sites, indulge in duty-free shopping, and enjoy the pristine beaches. St. Thomas offers a range of accommodations, including luxury resorts and smaller boutique hotels. The island’s appeal also extends to water sports enthusiasts, with opportunities for snorkeling, diving, and sailing.

Both destinations thrive on tourism, but Aruba’s focus on a diverse entertainment scene and sustainable practices sets it apart, while St. Thomas gains from its ties to the United States. and the range of activities it offers for travelers.

Natural Attractions and Outdoor Activities

Aruba and St. Thomas are blessed with natural beauty and a myriad of outdoor activities that cater to different interests.

Aruba’s arid landscape is home to unique natural wonders. The Arikok National Park showcases rugged coastlines, hidden caves, and stunning rock formations, such as the Natural Bridge and Natural Pool.

For their glistening waters and fine sands, the island’s pristine beaches, such as Eagle Beach and Palm Beach, are known. The tranquil and warm Caribbean Sea is a great place for kiteboarding, windsurfing, and snorkeling.

In contrast, St. Thomas captivates visitors with its lush hills, verdant rainforests, and picturesque beaches. Magens Bay, one of the most stunning beaches in the world, offers a serene haven with its clear seas and plush sand.

Coral World Ocean Park provides opportunities for marine exploration, allowing visitors to snorkel or take a semi-submarine tour. The island’s mountainous terrain also offers hiking trails, such as the famous 99 Steps in Charlotte Amalie, providing breathtaking views of the surrounding islands.

Both Aruba and St. Thomas offer a range of natural attractions and outdoor activities, catering to sun-seekers, adventure enthusiasts, and nature lovers. Whether you prefer exploring hidden caves or lounging on pristine beaches, these destinations have something for everyone.

Transportation and Accessibility

A pleasant and convenient travel experience depends heavily on transportation and accessibility. Let’s compare Aruba and St. Thomas in terms of transportation options and ease of accessibility.

Aruba boasts a modern and efficient transportation system. The island has an international airport, Queen Beatrix International Airport, which serves as a major hub connecting Aruba to various destinations worldwide. Taxis, rental automobiles, and public buses are all alternatives for guests to use once they arrive to navigate around the island.

It is simple to get around and experience Aruba at your own speed thanks to the island’s well-maintained road system. Additionally, many resorts and hotels provide shuttle services for their guests.

In St. Thomas, visitors also have the option to fly directly to the Cyril E. Flights both domestically and internationally are available from King Airport. The island has reliable taxi services available, but rental cars are a popular choice for travelers who want to explore at their leisure.

There is also public transportation, including open-air safaris and buses referred to as “safari taxis,” which provides a convenient way to travel the island and get a taste of the local way of life. Furthermore, St. Thomas is a popular port of call for cruise ships, providing easy access for cruise passengers to explore the island’s attractions.

Both Aruba and St. Thomas offer accessible transportation options, but Aruba’s extensive road network and availability of public buses provide slightly more convenience for travelers who prefer independent exploration.

Safety and Security

When selecting a destination for a trip, safety and security are essential considerations. Let’s examine the safety records of Aruba and St. Thomas to ensure peace of mind during your vacation.

Visitors can feel safe traveling to Aruba because of its reputation for having a low crime rate and a welcoming attitude. The local government and tourism authorities prioritize the safety of residents and tourists alike. Police presence is visible, particularly in tourist areas, providing a sense of security.

However, just as in any other holiday destination, it is still important to exercise common sense safety measures like protecting your valuables and paying attention to your surroundings.

St. Thomas, like many tourist destinations, experiences occasional incidents of petty theft and crime. The island has taken attempts to strengthen security measures and guarantee the protection of guests, though. It is advised to use caution, especially when handling valuables and in crowded situations.

Additionally, familiarize yourself with safety guidelines provided by local authorities and accommodations.

Both Aruba and St. Thomas are generally safe destinations, but Aruba’s reputation for its low crime rate and the visible presence of law enforcement may offer a slightly greater sense of security for travelers.

Aruba vs. St. Thomas (U.S. Virgin Islands) FAQ